*Retroactively awarded **Players who win an “MVP” award are not eligible to win one of the “All-Star” awards
| 2022 | 2021 | 2020 | 2019 | 2018 | 2017 | |
| Teammate of the Year | Savannah Landphier | Michelle Wehrman | Emily Haley | Sarah Michalski | Hannah Pfersch | |
| MVP Forward | Rachel Rank | Ronny Ruedinger | Hannah Pfersch | Hannah Pfersch | Hannah Pfersch | |
| MVP Back | Meghan Rank | Ayana Phelps | Taylor Fryda | Morgan Price | Lauren Leonardi | |
| Most Improved | Grace Farrell | Ronny Ruedinger | Norah Miller | Sydney Raymond | Mykayla Pena | |
| Rookie of the Year | Caitlyn Dieman | Heather Slamer | Brenna McLay | *Morgan Price | New team, not awarded | |
| All-Star Freshman | Natalie Lassiter | Macey St. Louis | Meghan Rank | Caralynn Doese | Connie Sebald | |
| All-Star Sophomore | Emma Kennedy | Grace Farrell | Ayana Phelps | Tierra Laurishke | Taylor Fryda | |
| All-Star Junior | Camille & Jasia Torres | Savannah Landphier | Michelle Wehrman | Taylor Fryda | MacKenzie Kolesari | |
| All-Star Senior | Ayana Phelps | Madi Martinez | Jessie Endries | Elise Rades | McKenzie Vang |
Hamilton RFC 